11/13/2026 06:49

Primary Care

Saying healthcare is broken in our country is something of a truism but that is not going to stop me. In actual reality perhaps the system is less broken than dwarfed (in the sense used for trees) or stunted (in the sense used of grains).

A lot of the problem, it seems to me, stems from our failure to talk about health carefully, rigorously, and objectively. We do not know what we mean by "health" or "healthcare" except that what WE mean is different from what other people mean. Often the term "healthcare" just means the system in place for paying for medical services. Other times it seems to encompass the culture of naming and selling products and services (especially those which help us to deny the effects of aging). As for "health" it is a word which connotes positive attributes but denotes only the absence of diagnosable conditions, meaning those encoded by the standardized classification of disease.

A considerable chunk of our current healthcare payment system is wrapped up in the concept of "primary care". As with the broader terms very little agreement exists about what this phrase should mean.

1. To medical specialists, "primary care" is akin to "primary school". The term encompasses simple services any physician might offer and leaves out any services the specialists have assigned as their own purview. The implication is that "primary care" is less significant than specialized care to a patient's health or that specialized care is more interesting and remunerative to the specialist.

2. To the health insurance companies, "primary care" is first in sequence. They look to primary care doctors as gatekeepers to whom a patient must apply in order to enter the expnsive world of specialized care. You must be sick enough and with the right sort of disease before the insurance company will pay for anything beyond basic examinations and common prescriptions. Judging how sick is sick enough is the role of primary care and turns the primary care provider into, primarily, a payer's agent rather than a provider of health services.

3. Many patients, in contrast, think "primary care" should be the foremost caregiving and the primary care provider should be the physician who has supervision and coordination over all the other health services offered to the patients.

So does "primary" mean "simple and basic" or the "first" of a series of gates and obstacles or the "foremost and preeminent"? All we have is a Humpty-Dumpty word which "means just what I choose it to mean -- neither more nor less."

If we can not define even so simple a term, how can we talk about promoting health in any sense beyond set treatments of named diseases? In actual reality we can't offer systematic improvements in "health care" until we become more careful about what we are saying.


Links